Does Gartner understand cloud computing?

Does Gartner understand cloud computing?

I like the Gartner Magic Quadrant. It provides for a quick overview of a specific domain, lists the key players and assigns them a high-level effectiveness rank. It’s a great tool, and also a very dangerous one. For those who understand a domain it provides reinforcement and a third-party perspective. And for those who don’t, it affords a quick way to select a vendor or choose a technology — the modern equivalent of “no-one gets fired for selecting IBM”.

Having placed many IaaS bets as a cloud management vendor, the Magic Quadrant for IaaS was something I was looking forward to review. But even at first glance it seemed a bit strange, with the title “Cloud Infrastructure as a Service and Web Hosting”. Hmmmm… So this is a review of IaaS, the very epitome of cloud services, and also of traditional web hosting services?

Reading through the report you will find similar idiosyncrasies and an obvious bias towards delivering ‘enterprise’ cloud services:

  • Security is called out multiple times, with no definition of what a secure cloud platform entails. Oddly enough, the paper doesn’t call out Amazon as a PCI-DSS compliant vendor, which is one of the clearer methods to show that one vendor is more secure than another.
  • Availability is a key requirement, preferably at 100% uptime. But while availability is important, cloud IaaS is not about giving you an always on website. Rather, cloud is about giving you the tools to make robust web applications that can easily manage with a failed node. If you need a 100% uptime web hosting solution then you should probably look for comparisons between the more traditional web hosts.
  • Professional services are oddly enough a key component of the IaaS cloud. You see, apparently it’s not cloud IaaS if it doesn’t come with a sales and consulting team to help you deploy it.

Security, availability and professional services — Gartner is clearly responding to dot-points mentioned to them by the large corporates that consume their material. And I daresay that these companies may not be needing cloud IaaS, but just want to be part of the hype.

You can see the oddity of it all in the actual Magic Quadrant (below). Amazon, considered to be miles ahead in features, mind-share and capabilities is listed as sub-par in “ability to execute”. Whilst your friendly corporate vendors, like AT&T and Verizon Business, show up as leaders of the group.

Many large companies practice what I like to call Architecture by Gartner, being quickly magnetized to whichever solutions appear in the Leader’s Quadrant. So while I don’t know who will be the winner of cloud IaaS for 2011, I can tell you that Savvis, AT&T, Rackspace, Verizon and Terremark will at least be having a very pleasant start to the year.

By Simon Ellis

About CloudTweaks

Established in 2009, CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading authorities in connected technology information and services.

We embrace and instill thought leadership insights, relevant and timely news related stories, unbiased benchmark reporting as well as offer green/cleantech learning and consultive services around the world.

Our vision is to create awareness and to help find innovative ways to connect our planet in a positive eco-friendly manner.

In the meantime, you may connect with CloudTweaks by following and sharing our resources.

View All Articles

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

Bimodal IT Is Not The Death of Traditional IT

Bimodal IT Is Not The Death of Traditional IT

Not The Death of Traditional IT If you are a CIO, no doubt you are getting pressure from your line of business managers to provide a more agile IT environment so they can take advantage of faster, easier to use cloud applications. If you’re not providing those services, they are probably using them anyway and…

Managed Services Providers (MSPs) – Urged To Embrace The Cloud

Managed Services Providers (MSPs) – Urged To Embrace The Cloud

Managed Services Providers (MSPs)  If you’ve been observant of the MSP industry over the last two years, you’ve no doubt noticed that it has had significant difficulty expanding its service capabilities and growing its revenue stream around cloud computing. At least that was the analysis of recent market research studies assessing the status of cloud…

Vendors To Enter The Cyber Security Game

Vendors To Enter The Cyber Security Game

IT Regulatory Compliance as the Next Big Focus for Cloud Vendors Back in October 2014, Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA) submitted a public request for information, calling for the assessment of the marketplace’s ability to “provide cloud ecosystems and services in two integration models that place vendor cloud services on DoD networks for use by…

Cyber Physical Systems (CPS) And BYOD Security

Cyber Physical Systems (CPS) And BYOD Security

Cyber Physical Systems (CPS)  Technology has changed the world radically. But, to date, the world hasn’t changed as fast as technology to. There are a couple of concepts that are concerning as we head into the reality of CPS-deployed systems. The first is that standards don’t exist. Many companies are considering the Bring Your Own…

The Evolution Of The Connected Cloud

The Evolution Of The Connected Cloud

The Connected Cloud Cloud computing is interesting first, but not only, because of the prevalence of cloud projects. There are many of them launched every day. Some have lofty expectations for business benefits (cost saving of 20 percent or more) and others carry even more intriguing goals. In 2005 “the cloud” was new. Shared computing…

The Global Rise of Cloud Computing

The Global Rise of Cloud Computing

The Global Rise of Cloud Computing Despite the rapid growth of cloud computing, the cloud still commands a small portion of overall enterprise IT spending. Estimates I’ve seen put the percentage between 5% and 10% of the slightly more than $2 trillion (not including telco) spent worldwide in 2014 on enterprise IT. Yet growth projections…

Drones: Unlimited Possibilities Await Us – Good And Bad

Drones: Unlimited Possibilities Await Us – Good And Bad

Drones: Unlimited Possibilities I have written two recent posts here on CloudTweaks about drones. The first, ‘The Pizza Delivery Drone’, was a somewhat comical look at what possibly is to come with future drones. The second was a look at the more immediately possible concept of a modular drone.  Modular drones are capable of supporting…

CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading influencers in cloud computing, infosec, big data and the internet of things (IoT) information. Our goal is to continue to build our growing information portal by providing the best in-depth articles, interviews, event listings, whitepapers, infographics and much more.

Advertising