Does Gartner understand cloud computing?

Does Gartner understand cloud computing?

By Simon Ellis of Labslice - CloudTweaks Contributor

I like the Gartner Magic Quadrant. It provides for a quick overview of a specific domain, lists the key players and assigns them a high-level effectiveness rank. It’s a great tool, and also a very dangerous one. For those who understand a domain it provides reinforcement and a third-party perspective. And for those who don’t, it affords a quick way to select a vendor or choose a technology — the modern equivalent of “no-one gets fired for selecting IBM”.

Having placed many IaaS bets as a cloud management vendor, the Magic Quadrant for IaaS was something I was looking forward to review. But even at first glance it seemed a bit strange, with the title “Cloud Infrastructure as a Service and Web Hosting”. Hmmmm… So this is a review of IaaS, the very epitome of cloud services, and also of traditional web hosting services?

Reading through the report you will find similar idiosyncrasies and an obvious bias towards delivering ‘enterprise’ cloud services:

  • Security is called out multiple times, with no definition of what a secure cloud platform entails. Oddly enough, the paper doesn’t call out Amazon as a PCI-DSS compliant vendor, which is one of the clearer methods to show that one vendor is more secure than another.
  • Availability is a key requirement, preferably at 100% uptime. But while availability is important, cloud IaaS is not about giving you an always on website. Rather, cloud is about giving you the tools to make robust web applications that can easily manage with a failed node. If you need a 100% uptime web hosting solution then you should probably look for comparisons between the more traditional web hosts.
  • Professional services are oddly enough a key component of the IaaS cloud. You see, apparently it’s not cloud IaaS if it doesn’t come with a sales and consulting team to help you deploy it.

Security, availability and professional services — Gartner is clearly responding to dot-points mentioned to them by the large corporates that consume their material. And I daresay that these companies may not be needing cloud IaaS, but just want to be part of the hype.

You can see the oddity of it all in the actual Magic Quadrant (below). Amazon, considered to be miles ahead in features, mind-share and capabilities is listed as sub-par in “ability to execute”. Whilst your friendly corporate vendors, like AT&T and Verizon Business, show up as leaders of the group.

Many large companies practice what I like to call Architecture by Gartner, being quickly magnetized to whichever solutions appear in the Leader’s Quadrant. So while I don’t know who will be the winner of cloud IaaS for 2011, I can tell you that Savvis, AT&T, Rackspace, Verizon and Terremark will at least be having a very pleasant start to the year.

Simon Ellis is the owner of labslice.com

LabSlice is a Virtual Lab Management solution powered by Amazon EC2.

FacebookTwitterLinkedInGoogle+Share

5 Responses to Does Gartner understand cloud computing?

Join Our Newsletter

Receive updates each week on news, tips, events, comics and much more...

Advertising Programs

Click To Find Out!

Sponsored Posts

Sponsored Posts

CloudTweaks has enjoyed a great relationship with many businesses, influencers and readers over the years, and it is one that we are interested in continuing. When we meet up with prospective clients, our intent is to establish a more solid relationship in which our clients invest in a campaign that consists of a number of

Popular

Top Viral Impact

Cloud Infographic – Big Data Survey: What Are The Trends?

Cloud Infographic – Big Data Survey: What Are The Trends?

Jaspersoft Big Data Survey Shows Rise in Commitment to Projects and Decline in Confusion Nearly 1,600 Jaspersoft Community Members Participate in Second Jaspersoft Big Data Survey San Francisco, February 4, 2014 – Jaspersoft, the Intelligence Inside applications and business processes, today shared results from its Big Data Survey. Nearly 1,600 Jaspersoft community members responded to

Cloud Infographic – The Power Of Cloud Disaster Recovery

Cloud Infographic – The Power Of Cloud Disaster Recovery

Cloud Infographic – The Power Of Cloud Disaster Recovery Preventing a Cloud Disaster is one thing. Recovering from a disaster is a whole other area of concern. Today’s infographic provided by CloudVelox outlines some best practices and safeguards in order to help your business make more informed decisions. About Latest Posts simon Latest posts by

2014 Future Of Cloud Computing Survey Results

2014 Future Of Cloud Computing Survey Results

Engine Yard Joins North Bridge Venture Partners, Gigaom Research and Industry Collaborators to Unveil 2014 Future of Cloud Computing Survey Results SAN FRANCISCO, CA–(Marketwired – Jun 25, 2014) – Engine Yard, the leading cloud application management platform, today announced its role as a collaborator in releasing the results of the fourth annual Future of Cloud Computing Survey,

Can I Contribute To CloudTweaks?

Yes, much of our focus in 2015 will be on working with other influencers in a collaborative manner. If you're a technology influencer looking to collaborate long term with CloudTweaks – a globally recognized leader in cloud computing information – drop us an email with “tech influencer” in the subject line.

Please review the guidelines before applying.

Whitepapers

Top Research Assets

HP OpenStack® Technology Breaking the Enterprise Barrier

HP OpenStack® Technology Breaking the Enterprise Barrier

Explore how cloud computing is a solution to the problems facing data centers today and highlights the cutting-edge technology (including OpenStack cloud computing) that HP is bringing to the current stage. If you are a CTO, data center administrator, systems architect, or an IT professional looking for an enterprise-grade, hybrid delivery cloud computing solution that’s open,

Public Cloud Flexibility, Private Cloud Security

Public Cloud Flexibility, Private Cloud Security

Public Cloud Flexibility, Private Cloud Security Cloud applications are a priority for every business – the technology is flexible, easy-to-use, and offers compelling economic benefits to the enterprise. The challenge is that cloud applications increase the potential for corporate data to leak, raising compliance and security concerns for IT. A primary security concern facing organizations moving