Gmail Outage – Is Cloud Computing To Blame?

Gmail Outage – Is Cloud Computing To Blame?

“There are no secrets to success. It is the result of preparation, hard work, and learning from failure.”
– Colin Powell, former US Secretary of State and Chairman of US Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Unless you are living under a rock, you must have come across the story of the Gmail outage a fortnight back. The question several observers are asking is, “Is cloud computing to blame?

First, here are the facts. On Sunday, 27 February, Gmail became inaccessible for some hours. When it did come back, several users were surprised to see their inboxes empty, other than two welcome messages from Google. Needless to say, they weren’t very pleased with it.

What added to their consternation was Google’s response, or rather lack of it. While it did put up a blog post assuring Gmail users that only 0.02% of users have been affected and that data recovery efforts were in progress, it did not give a timeline for the restoration to be completed. And there was good reason for Google’s reticence in declaring a time frame, considering it took them more than three days to solve the problem.

On Tuesday, 1 March, there were two updates at an interval of four hours. The first one said that service “has already been restored for some users, and we expect a resolution for all users in the near future. Please note this time frame is an estimate and may change.” This was followed by the update that “data for the remaining 0.012% of affected users has been successfully restored from tapes and is now being processed. We plan to begin moving data into mailboxes in 2 hours, and in the hours that follow users will regain access to their data. Accounts with more mail will take more time.

Finally, on Wednesday night (2 March), Google reported, “The problem with Google Mail should be resolved. We apologize for the inconvenience and thank you for your patience and continued support. Please rest assured that system reliability is a top priority at Google, and we are making continuous improvements to make our systems better.”

Now, Gmail is perhaps the most widely-used cloud computing-based service in the world today. Therefore, when it fails, even if only for three days, it does give rise to doubts on the dependability of the technology itself. Especially since Google had to resort to good old tapes to resolve the problem.

As for my opinion, I don’t believe that cloud computing as a whole should be blamed here. Yes, there were issues, but to use those as an excuse to deride or abandon cloud computing is akin to “throwing the baby out with the bathwater.” While multiple data centers as used in a cloud do provide redundancy, that quality is seriously undermined if the same software bug is allowed to penetrate each one of these data centers, as happened in this case.

Let’s look at one of the proposed alternatives to a cloud-based Gmail. Suppose all Gmail archival data is stored on tapes in a physical location, and that location is struck by an earthquake which destroys all the tapes, then how is that option any safer?

Here’s what CBS News technology correspondent Larry Magid had to say on the matter: “Look, anything has its risks. Any time there is an air disaster there are people who talk about why we shouldn’t fly, and then there are others who say, yes, but if you look at it compared to all the other ways of traveling, it’s much, much safer. I think that’s kind of what we’re dealing with right now. We did have – I wouldn’t call it a disaster – we had a serious problem, and it’s causing people like yourselves to question cloud computing. But you also have to look at it from the other side. For example, I am very capable of messing up my own system, thank you very much. Hard drives can crash; there are all sorts of risks on any type of technology. If you trade the hard drive for the cloud, in my opinion, you greatly decrease the risk of losing email.”

What people seem to forget is that cloud computing is a new technology scarcely a decade old, and consequently, vulnerable to teething problems (See: A History of Cloud Computing). Although I am in favor of the technology, I don’t deny the existence of manageable risks (See: Cloud Computing Risks (And How to Deal With Them). However, if weighed against the multiple benefits cloud computing offers (scalability, efficiencies, savings, etc,), the risks are definitely worth it.

As General Powell said, (the quote at the beginning of the article) learning from failure is one of the crucial ingredients of success. As long as Google learns from this incident, especially of the importance of true redundancy, cloud computing’s future is secure.

By Sourya Biswas

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

Comic
When Sci-Fi Predictions Come To Fruition

When Sci-Fi Predictions Come To Fruition

Evolution of Technologies To paraphrase science fiction author Arthur C. Clark, those who make predictions about the future are either “considered conservative now and mocked later, or mocked now and proved right when they are no longer around to enjoy the acclaim.” The one thing we can be sure about, Clark ventured, is that “[the…

Facebook Hopes To Extend Internet Connectivity With Solar-Powered Drones

Facebook Hopes To Extend Internet Connectivity With Solar-Powered Drones

Facebook Inc (FB.O) said on Thursday it had completed a successful test flight of a solar-powered drone that it hopes will help it extend internet connectivity to every corner of the planet. Aquila, Facebook’s lightweight, high-altitude aircraft, flew at a few thousand feet for 96 minutes in Yuma, Arizona, Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg wrote in…

When Will Women In Tech Become The Norm?

When Will Women In Tech Become The Norm?

Tech Diversity It is well known that the technology industry has been dominated by men, but it is also clear that the industry is working to change that. Diversity in the tech industry, especially where it applies to women in tech, has been a topic of discussion for years. Recently the Washington Technology Industry Association…

Four Keys For Telecoms Competing In A Digital World

Four Keys For Telecoms Competing In A Digital World

Competing in a Digital World Telecoms, otherwise largely known as Communications Service Providers (CSPs), have traditionally made the lion’s share of their revenue from providing pipes and infrastructure. Now CSPs face increased competition, not so much from each other, but with digital service providers (DSPs) like Netflix, Google, Amazon, Facebook, and Apple, all of whom…

Edtech and Virtual Reality – Exciting Learning Environment

Edtech and Virtual Reality – Exciting Learning Environment

Customizing Edutech Customized edtech learning solutions are becoming more commonplace as the education industry recognises their potential and begins transforming the traditional structures so as to incorporate innovative developments. From textbooks to tablets, chalkboards to virtual reality, edtech promises not only dynamic and exciting learning environments but better learning strategies and solutions. Virtual Reality and…

Are CEO’s Missing Out On Big Data’s Big Picture?

Are CEO’s Missing Out On Big Data’s Big Picture?

Big Data’s Big Picture Big data allows marketing and production strategists to see where their efforts are succeeding and where they need some work. With big data analytics, every move you make for your company can be backed by data and analytics. While every business venture involves some level of risk, with big data, that risk…

How You Can Improve Customer Experience With Fast Data Analytics

How You Can Improve Customer Experience With Fast Data Analytics

Fast Data Analytics In today’s constantly connected world, customers expect more than ever before from the companies they do business with. With the emergence of big data, businesses have been able to better meet and exceed customer expectations thanks to analytics and data science. However, the role of data in your business’ success doesn’t end…

Get Ready For Virtual Reality and the Cloud

Get Ready For Virtual Reality and the Cloud

Virtual Reality Cloud We’re lucky to live in an era where virtual reality is no longer relegated to the confines of a sci-fi movie universe. Thanks to technology introduced by products like Oculus Rift, consumers now have access to virtual environments with fully immersive graphic capabilities. As a result, companies have only just begun to…

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

There is a Difference – So Stop Comparing We are all familiar with the old saying “That’s like comparing apples to oranges” and though we learned this lesson during our early years we somehow seem to discount this idiom when discussing the Cloud. Specifically, IT buyers often feel justified when comparing the cost of a…

Shaking Up The Cloud Technology Marketplace

Shaking Up The Cloud Technology Marketplace

Cloud Technology Marketplace Cloud continues its devastating rearrangement of the technology marketplace. As legacy vendors struggle to compete many deck chairs are getting moved about – some pretty spectacularly. In the meantime, the boat is still sinking. We have seen how SaaS (Software as a Service) is tearing up traditional software firms who must adapt…

Cloud Computing Price War Rages On

Cloud Computing Price War Rages On

Cloud Computing Price War There’s little question that the business world is a competitive place, but probably no area in business truly defines cutthroat quite like cloud computing. At the moment, we are witnessing a heated price war pitting some of the top cloud providers against each other, all in a big way to attract…

5 Predictions For Education Technology

5 Predictions For Education Technology

Education Technology Although technology has fast influenced most sectors of our world, education is an area that’s lagged behind. Many classrooms still employ the one-to-many lecturing model wherein the average student is catered for while a few are left behind, and others bored. Recently, there’s been a drive to uncover how to use technology successfully…

Cloud Computing Myths That SMBs Should Know

Cloud Computing Myths That SMBs Should Know

Cloud Computing and SMBs Cloud Computing is the hottest issue among IT intellects of Small and Medium Businesses (SMBs). Like any other computer-orientated technology, Cloud Computing has some misconceptions and myths that often kick-start arguments among the two opposing groups: Cloud Supporters and Cloud Opponents. Both of these groups have their own ideology and reasons…

Infographic: The Evolving Internet of Things

Infographic: The Evolving Internet of Things

Evolving Internet of Things  The Internet of Things, or IoT, a term devised in 1999 by British entrepreneur Kevin Ashton, represents the connection of physical devices, systems and services via the internet, and Gartner and Lucas Blake’s new infographic (below) explores the evolution of the IoT industry, investigating its potential impact across just about every…

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations Everyone knows what the cloud is, but does everybody know where the cloud is? We try to answer that as we look at some of the most unusual data centre locations in the world. Under the Eyes of a Deity Deep beneath the famous Uspenski Cathedral in the…

The Questions of Privacy In The Internet of Things Revolution

The Questions of Privacy In The Internet of Things Revolution

Privacy in the Internet of Things Revolution The Internet of Things (IoT) has been promising a lot to consumers for a few years and now we’re really starting to see some of the big ideas come to fruition, which means an ever-growing conversation around data security and privacy. Big data comes with big responsibilities and…