Cloud Based Service Level Agreements – Two Different Worlds

Cloud Based Service Level Agreements – Two Different Worlds

Cloud Based Service Level Agreements

A common theme in the chatter about cloud computing is the need for SLAs around performance and availability. These SLAs simply don’t exist or are specified in a way that makes them look like they’ll never be violated. For example, Amazon’s availability SLA is around the network connectivity for an entire availability zone. So if you have a single instance that can access the internet (whether or not your app will run on it), there is no violation. This is hardly a new state of affairs and there doesn’t seem to be much change coming in future from the major providers. Some businesses and analysts view this as a show stopper/game changer while others could care less. Last week at Cloud Connect I had a moment of crystallization where the ideological divide that is fueling this and other cloud computing controversies became clear to me.

There are two dominant ways of looking at, and valuing the cloud that lead to very different philosophies about what it is and what SLAs should be: the cloud as a business model versus the cloud as a cost savings/efficiency device.  The former seems to be held by established companies and the latter by start-ups, although there are certainly exceptions on both sides.



The business model camp, exemplified by Netflix at Cloud Connect, views the cloud as a new way of operating. You design applications for the cloud explicitly using principles such as “design for failure” and automated provisioning of instances. At the extreme, you will terminate and create instances not just when you need more capacity but when any particular instance looks like it may not be 100% healthy. Also this happens in an automated fashion. In this case you need SLAs on the APIs, not the system.

Now Amazon’s system level availability SLA also makes sense.

As a result, providers can use junky, unreliable hardware and as long the provider has enough capacity (like Amazon) it just doesn’t matter. In this way you can ensure equally good performance as you’d get with dedicated infrastructure in a best case, but you avoid many bad cases where performance is degraded by a discrete set of failing servers. So overall average performance increases and becomes more consistent to boot. They money savings come in when your application scales to the capacity it needs at any given time. A happy side benefit is you no longer need to forecast capacity—an exercise that always produces an output that is wrong in some way.  Even if your load is steady and you don’t save money this way, the primary driver is about agility and consistent performance.

By contrast, the cost savings/efficiency camp views cloud computing as a logical extension of what you can do with virtualization in-house: save more money both in terms of capital and operating expenses. The savings seem substantial even if you don’t have the interest or capabilities to re-architect, although those who do get these savings as well.  Established businesses have the most to gain here since they already have a ton of existing applications and headcount. To get the savings, you directly migrate your applications to the public cloud. However, as you peel the onion you see a number of problems, such as what happens if you get provisioned onto an instance with greedy neighbor on it?  Worse is that those who architected their applications for the public cloud will detect this and move, leaving you more likely to get stuck in these situations overtime. So you ask the provider to assume the risk in a way you are familiar with: SLAs similar to what you get from your ISPs and in terms of performance guarantees.

So setting aside normative questions and religion, what does this all mean? Well one key point is that if you embrace the business model, you’ll save more money. You’ll also of course get all the benefits from the new model, like elasticity and agility—a point that the cost savings camp largely conceded at Cloud Connect. However, I’m a pragmatist. It is simply not realistic to expect a global enterprise to retool all its application en mas for the cloud. Being morally right has nothing to do with it.

This brings us to the interesting question.

Why would Amazon and company break down and offer the SLAs that the people want? I’m not so sure they will. Amazon is growing gangbusters and catering to the second group may hurt their ability to pursue the former, for marketing or technical reasons. The other major players who aspire to Amazon’s market are unlikely to break ranks either. Guess who may step in though? The carriers. After all, these are the guys who already offer the SLAs that the enterprise is accustomed to. So my prediction is that if this happens, you will quickly hear allegations that these “traditional SLA” backed services aren’t in fact ‘real’ cloud computing offerings and the schism will deepen.

As a final note, I have to say that I think in the long term, however many years it takes, more and more companies will embrace the business model approach to cloud computing. As I said, the experts on both sides seem to agree that designing for the cloud will save you more money and bring many other compelling and hard to ignore benefits to the business. If businesses subscribe to this line of thinking, it may well seem to Amazon and others that the right long term play is to ignore the customer.

So if you are waiting for better SLAs to be offered by the major cloud computing providers, you may be waiting a long time…

By Ian Withrow / Senior Product Manager Keynote Systems, Inc.

About CloudTweaks

Established in 2009, CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading authorities in connected technology information and services.

We embrace and instill thought leadership insights, relevant and timely news related stories, unbiased benchmark reporting as well as offer green/cleantech learning and consultive services around the world.

Our vision is to create awareness and to help find innovative ways to connect our planet in a positive eco-friendly manner.

In the meantime, you may connect with CloudTweaks by following and sharing our resources.

View All Articles

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

On Demand With The Gig Economy

On Demand With The Gig Economy

The Gig Economy By now, you’ve probably heard the phrase Gig Economy or seen services offered as “on-demand”. If you’re like 90 million Americans, then you’ve participated in this freelance workforce revolution as either a client or provider. The rise of apps connecting professional services, goods, and lodging directly to consumers via their smartphone is…

5 Cloud-Based Customer Service Trends

5 Cloud-Based Customer Service Trends

Customer Service Trends Customer service has become the new battleground in today’s marketplace. In fact, 97 percent of customers around the world now say that customer service makes a key difference in whether they decide to go with a brand or not, Microsoft reports. Many of the biggest changes in today’s customer service landscape center…

Conquering Disease with Artificial Intelligence and IBM Watson

Conquering Disease with Artificial Intelligence and IBM Watson

Artificial Intelligence and IBM Watson Artificial Intelligence, or AI, is growing increasingly pervasive in today’s modern world. Perhaps the most publicized and recognizable application of AI to date, IBM’s Jeopardy-winning computer, Watson, is now being used to help cure cancer. IBM announced the development of Watson for Genomics on Wednesday at the National Cancer Moonshot…

The Fundamentals of Predictive Analysis

The Fundamentals of Predictive Analysis

Predictive Analysis  Article sponsored by SAS Software and Big Data Forum Analytics is playing an increasingly important role in our lives thanks in large part to internet of things (IoT) developments and a greater appreciation of Big Data. With solutions that range across business productivity, health care, individual and national security, new insights are regularly…

Clouding Around With The Unicorns

Clouding Around With The Unicorns

The Social Unicorn Early investors and technology consumers alike love the poignantly named “Unicorn” companies, or private startups that reach the $1 billion valuation. The most recent unicorn spotting is social media game-changer Snapchat, which was recently valued at $16 billion. According to a recent infographic from Alexa discovered via Adweek, Snapchat also proves to…

Using Big Data To Analyze Venture Capitalists’ Ability To Recognize Potential

Using Big Data To Analyze Venture Capitalists’ Ability To Recognize Potential

Big Data To Analyze Using Big Data to Analyze Venture Capitalists’ Ability To Recognize Potential For those who are regularly involved with SMEs, venture capital, and company valuations, it is common knowledge that start-ups that exit for more than $1 billion dollars are extremely rare – often termed ‘unicorn’ companies. Despite their rarity, it should…

Infographic: The Evolving Internet of Things

Infographic: The Evolving Internet of Things

Evolving Internet of Things  The Internet of Things, or IoT, a term devised in 1999 by British entrepreneur Kevin Ashton, represents the connection of physical devices, systems and services via the internet, and Gartner and Lucas Blake’s new infographic (below) explores the evolution of the IoT industry, investigating its potential impact across just about every…

Utilizing Digital Marketing Techniques Via The Cloud

Utilizing Digital Marketing Techniques Via The Cloud

Digital Marketing Trends In the past, trends in the exceptionally fast-paced digital marketing arena have been quickly adopted or abandoned, keeping marketers and consumers on their toes. 2016 promises a similarly expeditious temperament, with a few new digital marketing offerings taking center stage. According to Gartner’s recent research into Digital Marketing Hubs, brands plan to…

7 Common Cloud Security Missteps

7 Common Cloud Security Missteps

Cloud Security Missteps Cloud computing remains shrouded in mystery for the average American. The most common sentiment is, “It’s not secure.” Few realize how many cloud applications they access every day: Facebook, Gmail, Uber, Evernote, Venmo, and the list goes on and on… People flock to cloud services for convenient solutions to everyday tasks. They…

Shadow IT To Remain A Focus For Both Cloud Vendors And CIOs

Shadow IT To Remain A Focus For Both Cloud Vendors And CIOs

Shadow IT To Remain A Focus Shadow IT, a phenomenon defined as building internal IT systems without the official organizational approval has been a growing concern for CIOs over the last few years. In 2015, it climbed to the top of the list of the emerging IT threats, with as much as 83% CIOs reporting…

6 Tech Predictions To Have A Major Impact In 2016

6 Tech Predictions To Have A Major Impact In 2016

6 Tech Predictions To Have A Major Impact The technology industry moves at a relentless pace, making it both exhilarating and unforgiving. For those at the forefront of innovation it is an incredibly exciting place to be, but what trends are we likely to see coming to the fore in 2016? Below are six predictions…

What Top SaaS Vendors Do To Ensure Successful Onboarding

What Top SaaS Vendors Do To Ensure Successful Onboarding

What Top SaaS Vendors Do I am not going to mention names in this article, but if you want to be the best, you must look at what the best do – and do it better. The importance of investing in SaaS onboarding can be easily overlooked in favor of designing efficient and powerful software…