How Amazon Brainwashed Us All (and Joyent Too)

How Amazon Brainwashed Us All (and Joyent Too)

How Amazon Brainwashed Us All (and Joyent Too)

When you enjoy a first-mover advantage in a new market as Amazon has for the last 7 years in the public cloud, you get to dictate the terms of the initial conversation (Think Henry Ford “You can have any color so long as it’s black”). That doesn’t mean we all have to keep listening, though, allowing them to brainwash everyone into thinking about cloud exclusively in a way that plays to their advantages. Instead of challenging Amazon to stick to the fundamentals of flexibility that supposedly necessitated the public cloud in the first place, companies like Joyent are following along…

Why cloud in the first place?

Remember this?


(Image Source – thanks,

This is the diagram that justified public cloud, showing how in a classic on-premise solution you were forced into capital expense based on future capacity predictions. With cloud, we were told, you don’t have to make predictions which are ultimately doomed to failure anyway causing either an overcapacity spending nightmare or an under capacity business limiting situation. It’s supposed to be about flexibility.

At least, until it’s inconvenient for Amazon to be flexible.

The deal you REALLY make with Amazon

When you sign up for AWS, the deal you’re really making is that you’ll agree the following:

  • I’ll let you dictate to me what sizes my VMs can be. Instead of letting me pick how many CPU cores and how much RAM I need for my workload, I’ll choose from among 18 sizes you pick for me and pay for resources I don’t need. After all, those cookie-cutter sizes make the multi-tenancy density easier and more profitable for you so I’ll do my part by paying for things I won’t use.
  • I can’t possibly expect consistent performance from my VMs. Is that fair to you, really? Instead of holding you accountable for any quality, I’ll design around it with a deployment strategy that launches five VMs, runs performance benchmarks on each, and keeps the one good one.
  • If I need to scale, I’ll do so horizontally. Why even consider a vertical scaling option? All my apps were designed with an on-premise solution in mind where we could add memory whenever we wanted to. I’m sure running something intended for a single machine will run on multiple VMs just fine as my demand grows. What could possibly go wrong?
  • To get the best pricing, I’ll predict how much resource I expect to need and pay you a large upfront fee. I don’t even have to recoup all of it if my predictions were wrong. I’d just like to reserve that price for resources I might not use.

Wait a minute, what about that last one? Isn’t cloud supposed to be flexible resources on-demand instead of making a prediction on capacity need that will ultimately be incorrect? So how come the best AWS pricing comes with that exact same model?

Don’t ask Joyent, they just did the same exact thing.

A hypnotized market

The conversation around public cloud is starting to resemble that old Jon Lovitz SNL skit about the hypnotist with a Broadway show (Amazing Alexander, thanks Hulu) where too many people keep repeating the same lines Amazon feeds them over and over again. Amazon’s business model is to buy commodity hardware at insane volume direct from manufacturers and then sell a notion of flexibility that isn’t what it could be. It’s better than the old on-premise world, but when you overhear someone at a trade show debating the merits of a m1.xlarge vs a m2.xlarge vs m2.2xlarge instead of just how many CPU cores and how much RAM they actually need, there’s room for improvement.

So when Joyent announced support for reserved pricing in a model very similar to what Amazon is doing, not only are they chasing a competitor whose economies of scale they probably can’t match they are sending a dangerous signal to the marketplace that the status quo is just fine.

It isn’t.

Worldwide IT spend is estimated to be around $4 trillion and public cloud spend only $4 billion. What are the 99.9% waiting for? Something better.

Price/Performance > Price

There’s growing sentiment that price/performance should be a part of the purchase decision. Value with anything, including public cloud, is derived from a combination of factors and getting started with a performance characterization of public cloud providers has never been easier. Third party cloud benchmarking and performance reports, like those available from Cloud Spectator, can provide a guide for narrowing choices among IaaS vendors before running your own application-specific tests. Only then, and when considering flexibility factors, can you truly judge the total cost of ownership for a cloud solution.

The bottom line is that Amazon got to define the way the market things about public cloud functionality by going first, but that doesn’t mean they get to own the definition in perpetuity. As Rackspace CEO Lew Moorman recently saidWhen public cloud came out, and you could suddenly provision a server in a minute when it used to take 3 months, those were intoxicating advances. . . you get drunk on them, but when things settle in there are tradeoffs.” As a consumer, you owe it to yourself to explore what those tradeoffs are and in what choices Amazon is falling short in not providing.

By Pete Johnson,

Senior Director of Cloud Platform Evangelism, ProfitBricks

After a 19-year career with HP that included a 6-year stint running Enterprise Architecture for as well as being a founding member of HP’s public cloud efforts, Pete Johnson joined ProfitBricks in February 2013 as Senior Director of Cloud Platform Evangelism. @nerdguru on Twitter, Pete is active in social media, trade shows, and meet ups to raise awareness of Cloud Computing 2.0 from ProfitBricks.

Follow Us!


Established in 2009, is recognized as one of the leading authorities in cloud computing information. Most of the excellent CloudTweaks articles are provided by our own paid writers, with a small percentage provided by guest authors from around the globe, including CEOs, CIOs, Technology bloggers and Cloud enthusiasts. Our goal is to continue to build a growing community offering the best in-depth articles, interviews, event listings, whitepapers, infographics and much more...
Follow Us!

Latest posts by CloudTweaks (see all)

One Response to How Amazon Brainwashed Us All (and Joyent Too)

5 Considerations You Need To Review Before Investing In Data Analytics

5 Considerations You Need To Review Before Investing In Data Analytics

Review Before Investing In Data Analytics Big data, when handled properly, can lead to big change. Companies in a wide variety of industries are partnering with data analytics companies to increase operational efficiency and make evidence-based business decisions. From Kraft Foods using business intelligence (BI) to cut customer satisfaction analysis time in half, to a…

Cloud Computing Offers Key Benefits For Small, Medium Businesses

Cloud Computing Offers Key Benefits For Small, Medium Businesses

A growing number of small and medium businesses in the United States rely on as a means of deploying mission-critical software products. Prior to the advent of cloud-based products — software solutions delivered over the Internet – companies were often forced to invest in servers and other products to run software and store data. The…

Cloud Infographic – Monetizing Internet Of Things

Cloud Infographic – Monetizing Internet Of Things

Cloud Infographic – Monetizing Internet Of Things There are many interesting ways in which companies are looking to connect devices to the cloud. From the vehicles to kitchen appliances the internet of things is already a $1.9 trillion dollar market based on research estimates from IDC. Included is a fascinating infographic provided by AriaSystems which shows us some…

Cloud Computing Adoption Continues

Cloud Computing Adoption Continues

Cloud Computing Adoption Continues Nowadays, many companies are changing their overall information technology strategies to embrace cloud computing in order to open up business opportunities.  There are numerous definitions of cloud computing. Simply speaking, the term “cloud computing” comes from network diagrams in which cloud shapes are  used to describe certain types of networks. All…

Cloud Infographic – The Future Of Big Data

Cloud Infographic – The Future Of Big Data

The Future Of Big Data Big Data is BIG business and will continue to be one of the more predominant areas of focus in the coming years from small startups to large scale corporations. We’ve already covered on CloudTweaks how Big Data can be utilized in a number of interesting ways from preventing world hunger to helping teams win…



Cloud Logo Sponsors

hp Logo CityCloud-PoweredByOpenstack-Bluesquare_logo_100x100-01
cisco_logo_100x100 vmware citrix100
Site 24x7

Contributor Spotlight

Established in 2009, CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading influencers in cloud computing, big data and internet of things (IoT) information. Our goal is to continue to build our growing information portal, by providing the best in-depth articles, interviews, event listings, whitepapers, infographics and much more.


CloudTweaks Media
Phone: 1 (212) 763-0021

Branded Content Programs