Online Powerhouses – Too Big to Sue?

Online Powerhouses – Too Big to Sue?

Online Powerhouses – Too Big to Sue?

Internet privacy is not just under siege from the NSA. Google is fighting two huge class action suits based upon privacy violations. Facebook recently settled two privacy-based class action lawsuits. These lawsuits are colossal because Google and Facebook are two mammoth companies with enormous numbers of customers. One class is comprised of everyone who has a Gmail account or sent a message to a GMail account over the last two years. How huge is that? The last time Google released the number of Gmail accounts was in June, 2012: 425 million worldwide. I’ve opened two myself since then.  But that’s only the number of Gmail accounts and doesn’t include everyone sending messages to Gmail accounts. Facebook boasts over 1 billion users. We mean huge.

Facebook-legal

(Image Source: Shutterstock)

The second Google case is In re Google Street View Electronic Communications Litigation. This class is every person in the US whose home WiFi Google tapped to perform its street view mapping. No one knows how many people that is, but it could be in the millions.

While lawyers typically look for moneyed defendants, the problem with lawsuits of this magnitude is that each privacy violation has a statutory penalty of up to $10,000 under the Wiretap Act. When the class of plaintiffs is so large, the penalties rapidly hit billions or even trillions of dollars – that is if every class member decides to participate.

So what does this really look like? Facebook lucked out on its class action, Fraley v. Facebook, when the judge approved a settlement in August to pay each class member $15. The potential class included 150 million users but only 615,000 filed claims. Facebook paid $20 million into a settlement fund with $9,225,000 going to class members; $5,000,000 to Internet privacy watch dog groups, called cy pres awards; and $3.5 million in attorneys’ fees. So Facebook is lucky because $20 million is far less than $2.25 billion (150 million members x $15). If each class member got $1,000, more would likely have signed up and well, you can do the math.

Facebook managed to settle its next class action on the Beacon program (Let’s broadcast details about our users’ personal lives!) with a $6 million cy pres award to a privacy group Facebook controls. Clearly Facebook thought it “cracked the code” on managing its privacy problems but the case is being appealed. And what’s more, settling class actions with cy pres awards in lieu of compensating individuals is now losing favor in the 9th Circuit where Google and Facebook live.

The Google cases have been progressing through the litigation process with the plaintiffs largely winning. Even with gross revenues of $50 billion in 2012, awarding significant damages to each class member would likely bankrupt Google, leaving the claimants without payments and hundreds of millions without services.

Some commentators are arguing that the suits are “Too Big to Settle”. In the class action world, once the class is certified by the court, settlements are very difficult. What usually happens is that prior to certification, the parties come up with their proposed settlement and present it to the court for approval. Once the class is certified, it’s up to the court to define the award. If the court won’t accept a cy pres award and applies statutory damages to each class member, we are looking at staggering judgments.

It’s reminiscent of the “Too Big to Fail” arguments of the big banks and auto companies. But do they warrant it? However you feel about class action suits, shouldn’t Google and Facebook be held accountable for privacy violations even though they are so large – or because they are so large? Would the impact of Google’s or Facebook’s demise be similar to bringing down the banking system or the auto industry? Or would the Internet ecosystem hiccup and move on?

The U.S. Supreme Court should announce if they will take the appeal of the Beacon Facebook class action and its cy pres award on Monday. Any bets?

By Cindy Wolf

Cindy is a Colorado lawyer with more than 25 years experience representing large and small domestic and multinational companies. Her expertise is in helping companies enter the cloud safely, either as providers or users. She also practices in the areas of corporate law and commercial contracting, with an emphasis on international issues. She can be reached at cindy@cindywolf.com. 

(Note: This publication is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. There is no implicit guarantee that this information is correct, complete, or up to date. This publication is not intended to and does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the author.)

About CloudTweaks

Established in 2009, CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading authorities in connected technology information and services.

We embrace and instill thought leadership insights, relevant and timely news related stories, unbiased benchmark reporting as well as offer green/cleantech learning and consultive services around the world.

Our vision is to create awareness and to help find innovative ways to connect our planet in a positive eco-friendly manner.

In the meantime, you may connect with CloudTweaks by following and sharing our resources.

View All Articles

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

Connecting With Customers In The Cloud

Connecting With Customers In The Cloud

Customers in the Cloud Global enterprises in every industry are increasingly turning to cloud-based innovators like Salesforce, ServiceNow, WorkDay and Aria, to handle critical systems like billing, IT services, HCM and CRM. One need look no further than Salesforce’s and Amazon’s most recent earnings report, to see this indeed is not a passing fad, but…

Staying on Top of Your Infrastructure-as-a-Service Security Responsibilities

Staying on Top of Your Infrastructure-as-a-Service Security Responsibilities

Infrastructure-as-a-Service Security It’s no secret many organizations rely on popular cloud providers like Amazon and Microsoft for access to computing infrastructure. The many perks of cloud services, such as the ability to quickly scale resources without the upfront cost of buying physical servers, have helped build a multibillion-dollar cloud industry that continues to grow each…

Cloud-Based or On-Premise ERP Deployment? Find Out

Cloud-Based or On-Premise ERP Deployment? Find Out

ERP Deployment You know how ERP deployment can improve processes within your supply chain, and the things to keep in mind when implementing an ERP system. But do you know if cloud-based or on-premise ERP deployment is better for your company or industry? While cloud computing is becoming more and more popular, it is worth…

How The CFAA Ruling Affects Individuals And Password-Sharing

How The CFAA Ruling Affects Individuals And Password-Sharing

Individuals and Password-Sharing With the 1980s came the explosion of computing. In 1980, the Commodore ushered in the advent of home computing. Time magazine declared 1982 was “The Year of the Computer.” By 1983, there were an estimated 10 million personal computers in the United States alone. As soon as computers became popular, the federal government…

5% Of Companies Have Embraced The Digital Innovation Fostered By Cloud Computing

5% Of Companies Have Embraced The Digital Innovation Fostered By Cloud Computing

Embracing The Cloud We love the stories of big complacent industry leaders having their positions sledge hammered by nimble cloud-based competitors. Saleforce.com chews up Oracle’s CRM business. Airbnb has a bigger market cap than Marriott. Amazon crushes Walmart (and pretty much every other retailer). We say: “How could they have not seen this coming?” But, more…

The Cloud Is Not Enough! Why Businesses Need Hybrid Solutions

The Cloud Is Not Enough! Why Businesses Need Hybrid Solutions

Why Businesses Need Hybrid Solutions Running a cloud server is no longer the novel trend it once was. Now, the cloud is a necessary data tier that allows employees to access vital company data and maintain productivity from anywhere in the world. But it isn’t a perfect system — security and performance issues can quickly…

The Security Gap: What Is Your Core Strength?

The Security Gap: What Is Your Core Strength?

The Security Gap You’re out of your mind if you think blocking access to file sharing services is filling a security gap. You’re out of your mind if you think making people jump through hoops like Citrix and VPNs to get at content is secure. You’re out of your mind if you think putting your…

7 Common Cloud Security Missteps

7 Common Cloud Security Missteps

Cloud Security Missteps Cloud computing remains shrouded in mystery for the average American. The most common sentiment is, “It’s not secure.” Few realize how many cloud applications they access every day: Facebook, Gmail, Uber, Evernote, Venmo, and the list goes on and on… People flock to cloud services for convenient solutions to everyday tasks. They…