Endurance – A New Way To Measure Churn

Endurance – A New Way To Measure Churn

Endurance – A New Way To Measure Churn

Being in the Hosting industry for over 15 years, an IPO of any Hosting company always intrigues me. You can always learn more information and get new insights into their business from their Prospectus & Roadshow presentations. I closely watched Endurance presentations, and their claim of “1% Churn” got my attention. They have repeated that claim on their Q4-2013 earnings call while defining the MRR retention at 99%. They have kept that statement in their Q1-2014 results. Endurance International Group Holdings, Inc. (Nasdaq:EIGI) is a leading provider of cloud-based platform solutions designed to help small and medium-sized businesses succeed online

Out of the over 50+ companies that were bought over the past years, there are a few which were players in the Hosting market for many years and were struggling with churn throughout those years. Included among them are: HostCentric, Hostmonster, Bizland, homestead, domain.com, Ehost, ApolloHosting.

I wondered what the Endurance team did in order to reduce the industry-inherited churn in these companies.

Before I jump into my analysis of endurance and churn numbers, I would like to refresh your memory about the churn of SaaS companies in general and Hosting ones in particular. See for example, my previous articles. As demonstrated, churn is always an issue in any subscription-based businesses. There are however situations in which Churn is to be expected and is more or less bearable, while in others it is like a cancer to the SaaS organism.

Endurance 1% Churn Model

Before I begin, I would like to present the following disclaimer: as I did not speak to the endurance team nor to analyst which covers them, the below analysis , is based on my own 15 years of experience in the industry and on the material they have chosen to share with their investors during their roadshow. Therefore, I might be completely wrong….

MRR Explained

Let’s assume that on January 2013, a SaaS company had 100 new customers joining one of their Hosting brands. Assuming each customer would sign on for a subscription account of $10/Month plan, we would see an MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue) of: 100 customers X $10/mo. = $1,000 MRR.

Recognized Revenues

Recognized revenues in a SaaS company refer to revenues for services actually being rendered to the customers. And in a Hosting company, in which the service is a monthly hosting service, over the course of each month the customer got the service he paid for, and the company can recognize the resulting revenues for that month.

Assuming all customers pay either on a monthly base or upfront for a yearly plan, their monthly recognized revenues would be equal to the MRR (for monthly paying customers they would recognize all of their monthly payment, while for yearly plans they would recognize 1/12 of their payment for each month of service). $1,000 MRR = $1,000 Recognized revenues.

However, in our case, January 2013 was the 1st month those 100 customers subscribed to the service. In such a case, those customers would join throughout the month, as the sales & marketing activities are spread over the month.

For the sake of this calculation we assume an even spread over the month. Therefore, on average, each customer would get a service of 15 days out of the month. In such a case, they would recognize only 50% of his monthly payment (while deferring the remaining amount to the following month). Therefore, their collection would be: 100 customers X $10 each = $1,000

However, their recognized revenues would only be 50% of that, as they delivered service for 50% of the month, on average: $1,000 X 50% = $500 Recognized Revenues

Impact on Recognized Revenues

On the following month, assuming they would keep all of their customers, the service will be rendered for a full month and therefore: $1,000 MRR = $1,000 Recognized Revenues

This means that the contribution of the customers who joined on January 2013 to their aggregated recognized revenues would be doubled during February 2013, and would remain the same for the following months, assuming none of the customers would leave the service.

Ongoing Model

Now, in order to demonstrate a bit, let’s look at several months outlook while pinpointing the cohorts:

Revenues

We can see here, that our numbers are growing on the total user base, while our cohorts are being churned. Clearly, when time passes and the amount of users joining will be equal to the amount of those who are leaving, we will be in the classical “churn trap.” However, all those are not new to us, but let’s look at the Rec. Rev. Model Endurance are using:

Recognized Revenue Model

revenues22

Comments:

  1. They would recognize only 50% of the MRR the new customers generate (on an average 15 days a month).
  2. 20 customers canceled that month, but on average they did got a service for 15 days on an average.
  3. Same goes here with 10 customers leaving.

What we could see here, is that by using the Rev. Rec. guidelines we are “flattening” the impact of the churn on the revenues (not on the MRR), by differing revenues of new customers to the following month, and by recognizing revenues & differed revenues of customers who are leaving that month.

Summary

I learned few things from this exercise:

  1.  The Endurance guys used in their analysis a model which is not the industry common practice, while using industry terminology.
  2.  Their businesses suffers from the same issues other ‘hosters’ suffer, and most probably at the same level.
  3.  Revenues recognition guidelines may need to be modified for the use of SaaS subscriptions companies, as MRR would better reflect their upcoming financial outlook.

In summary, Churn has always been a key performance indicator of a Hosting company. No hosting company can avoid it, and they all continue to struggle to minimize it.
However, the churn should be dealt with product, operational and service manners and not by the finance department…..

Roy-SaaR

Roy Saar  is a partner at Mangrove Capital Partners, a bold but patient venture capital firm helping innovative entrepreneurs start and grow global, disruptive companies. was involved in the launch of Wix. Roy was also the founder of Sphera Technologies (sold to Parallels in 2007), which was one of the very first software platforms for SaaS providers. Roy seats on the boards of: WIX, WalkMe & RFcell

About CloudTweaks

Established in 2009, CloudTweaks is recognized as one of the leading authorities in connected technology information and services.

We embrace and instill thought leadership insights, relevant and timely news related stories, unbiased benchmark reporting as well as offer green/cleantech learning and consultive services around the world.

Our vision is to create awareness and to help find innovative ways to connect our planet in a positive eco-friendly manner.

In the meantime, you may connect with CloudTweaks by following and sharing our resources.

View All Articles

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

Comic
Fully Autonomous Cars: How’s It REALLY Going To Work?

Fully Autonomous Cars: How’s It REALLY Going To Work?

Pros and Cons and What the Experts Think Science fiction meets reality, and modern civilization is excitedly looking forward to the ubiquity of self-driving cars. However, an omnipresence of fully autonomous cars won’t happen as quickly as even some hopeful experts anticipate. While the autonomous car pros versus the cons race (See infographic discovered via…

The Lighter Side Of The Cloud – Bottlenecking

The Lighter Side Of The Cloud – Bottlenecking

By David Fletcher Please feel free to share our comics via social media networks such as Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, Pinterest. Clear attribution (Twitter example: via @cloudtweaks) to our original comic sources is greatly appreciated.

Recent Articles - Posted by
Fintech Systems, Advancements and Investments

Fintech Systems, Advancements and Investments

Fintech Growth According to a recent report, global investment in fintech companies including both venture-backed and non-venture-backed businesses reached $9.4 billion in the second quarter of 2016; investment in venture capital-backed fintech startups, however, fell by 49%. Nevertheless, the Pulse of Fintech, published jointly by KPMG International and CB Insights, suggests venture capital investment in…

How Identity Governance Can Secure The Cloud Enterprise

How Identity Governance Can Secure The Cloud Enterprise

Securing The Cloud Enterprise Cloud adoption is accelerating for most enterprises, and cloud computing is becoming an integral part of enterprise IT and security infrastructure. Based on current adoption trends, it’s clear that the vast majority of new applications purchased by organizations will be SaaS applications. The allure is evident, from cost savings to speed…

Ending The Great Enterprise Disconnect

Ending The Great Enterprise Disconnect

Five Requirements for Supporting a Connected Workforce It used to be that enterprises dictated how workers spent their day: stuck in a cubicle, tied to an enterprise-mandated computer, an enterprise-mandated desk phone with mysterious buttons, and perhaps an enterprise-mandated mobile phone if they traveled. All that is history. Today, a modern workforce is dictating how…

How To Humanize Your Data (And Why You Need To)

How To Humanize Your Data (And Why You Need To)

How To Humanize Your Data The modern enterprise is digital. It relies on accurate and timely data to support the information and process needs of its workforce and its customers. However, data suffers from a likability crisis. It’s as essential to us as oxygen, but because we don’t see it, we take it for granted.…

The Cancer Moonshot: Collaboration Is Key

The Cancer Moonshot: Collaboration Is Key

Cancer Moonshot In his final State of the Union address in January 2016, President Obama announced a new American “moonshot” effort: finding a cure for cancer. The term “moonshot” comes from one of America’s greatest achievements, the moon landing. If the scientific community can achieve that kind of feat, then surely it can rally around…

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

There is a Difference – So Stop Comparing We are all familiar with the old saying “That’s like comparing apples to oranges” and though we learned this lesson during our early years we somehow seem to discount this idiom when discussing the Cloud. Specifically, IT buyers often feel justified when comparing the cost of a…

What Top SaaS Vendors Do To Ensure Successful Onboarding

What Top SaaS Vendors Do To Ensure Successful Onboarding

What Top SaaS Vendors Do I am not going to mention names in this article, but if you want to be the best, you must look at what the best do – and do it better. The importance of investing in SaaS onboarding can be easily overlooked in favor of designing efficient and powerful software…

The Future Of Cybersecurity

The Future Of Cybersecurity

The Future of Cybersecurity In 2013, President Obama issued an Executive Order to protect critical infrastructure by establishing baseline security standards. One year later, the government announced the cybersecurity framework, a voluntary how-to guide to strengthen cybersecurity and meanwhile, the Senate Intelligence Committee voted to approve the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act (CISA), moving it one…

The Internet of Things – Redefining The Digital World As We Know It

The Internet of Things – Redefining The Digital World As We Know It

Redefining The Digital World According to Internet World Stats (June 30th, 2015), no fewer than 3.2 billion people across the world now use the internet in one way or another. This means an incredible amount of data sharing through the utilization of API’s, Cloud platforms and inevitably the world of connected Things. The Internet of Things is a…

How Big Data Is Influencing Web Design

How Big Data Is Influencing Web Design

How Big Data Is Influencing Web Design For all you non-techies… You’re probably wondering what big data is (I know I was….a few years back) so let’s get the definitions out of the way so we’re on the same page, okay? Big data is A LOT of data – really, it is. It is a…

Teach Yourself The Cloud: Cloud Computing Knowledge In 5 Easy Steps

Teach Yourself The Cloud: Cloud Computing Knowledge In 5 Easy Steps

Teach Yourself The Cloud Learn how to get to grips with cloud computing in business  Struggling to get your head around the Cloud? Here are five easy ways you can improve your cloud knowledge and perhaps even introduce cloud systems into your business.  Any new technology can appear daunting, and cloud computing is no exception.…

Moving Your Enterprise Apps To The Cloud Is A Business Decision

Moving Your Enterprise Apps To The Cloud Is A Business Decision

Moving Your Enterprise Apps Whether it be enterprise apps or any other, if there is any heavy data that is going to be transacted in and through an app, then affiliating it with the Cloud becomes a must. And then an important question arises: How do you decide when to integrate your enterprise app with…