Critical Thinking And Big Data

In a deeply moving TED talk about the importance of critical thinking when dealing with data, big or small, Susan Etlinger reminds us why it’s important to think twice before assuming anything, even when backed up by data. Inevitably, morality comes into play too. As more and more problems, including perhaps fundamental ones, are tackled by data, it’s easy to see why.

Consider this: if data tells us that bombing a foreign country will save more lives than it will erase, should we strike at once? Of course not, but what if it’s a research facility or a weapons factory?Let’s move, however, to something more prosaic – and slightly less frightening.

Doing ‘something’ with data

Cities like New York and Washington launched so-called ‘app contests’ where developers took the city’s now-open data and made apps out of it. Sounds good, but the first app contests didn’t produce anything of value as cities didn’t specify problems that had to be solved. So the developers came along and created a lot of cool, not necessarily useful stuff. Even the magnificent Trees Near You, an app that shows people the trees near their smartphone and that came right out the NYC BigApps competition, has long gone defunct. Only recently cities have become more prudent in making such app contents, whereas beforehand the prize money went right down the drain.

The trouble is, when you have so much data, it simply becomes tempting to do something, anything with it. While the topic of TED is still fresh in your memory, you probably remember Ken Robinson’s talk about what education needs to be. It is debatable in many respects, but it’s wrong in interpreting data (particularly as concerns the ‘Ritalin epidemic’). Just like the cities, Robinson wanted to do something with the data, but in this case it was something in particular.

Risks to the public

Even though Big Data can be and is utilized in areas such as healthcare, mapping crime and, well, to generally improve people’s lives, it’s evident that an increasingly digitized world needs us to set firm boundaries about what we do and don’t do with Big Data. It has confirmed, for example, that it’s good to, say, give homeless people housing. But what if it wouldn’t?

Facts are stubborn things” indeed. In face of budget considerations, there’s a risk to slip into a queasy state of semi-contentedness when we don’t do something that’s right because data confirms that it costs more to do it. This isn’t limited to the public sector, of course. Laying off hundreds of workers has an immense social impact, but you can’t argue with the free market, especially if it’s coupled with love for numbers.

People should not give up on Big Data. It can and does improve, sometimes save lives, like in the case of sophisticated weather forecasts, or predicting possible landslides at Rio de Janeiro. It’s just that progress should be made in small increments, involving the faculty of reason above all, but feeling as well.

By Lauris Veips

Viral Infection Wearabletech
Holiday Access.png
Twitbook.png
Disaster Recovery Plan.png
Gary Bernstein
Secure Remote Authentication When employees are working remotely, they need to be able to access company resources and applications just as if they were in the office. This means that remote authentication needs to be ...
Dinesh Varadharajan
The Future with Automation Many entrepreneurs believe digital technologies will transform the way their companies work. By 2022, the worldwide hyper-automation technology market is expected to be worth $596.6 billion. And by 2055, almost half ...
Gary Bernstein
A Framework to Manage Your Data A data management framework is the key to understanding and controlling your data. By following a few simple tips and strategies, you can put this framework into place in ...
Gilad David Maayan
What is Open Source Security? Open source software is now an inseparable part of most software projects. Research has estimated that as much as 90% of enterprise software is made up of open source components ...
Louis
Devops teams are sacrificing focus on security gate reviews to meet tight time-to-market deadlines amid growing pressure to deliver digital transformation and digital-first revenue projects ahead of schedule. Compensation plans for CIOs, devops leaders, and their teams prioritize time-to-market performance, ...