Financial Robo-advisors Cannot Replace Humans

Financial Robo-advisors

Last year we saw the rise of numerous robo-advisors, bots, and investing robots that are considered a disruptive force within the financial industry. All the media hype aside, these tools have a long way to go before they could be considered a replacement for human-made investment decisions.

The online universe is now full of robo-advisors and bots that run in the cloud or on specific websites, providing services ranging from simple investment advice to portfolio management. Estimations are that robo-advisors have managed about $15 billion in financial assets by end-2015. On the other hand, investment banks like Charles Schwab, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, and Deutsche Bank manage investment funds that are in the range of trillions of dollars. Most of them rely heavily on human-made investment decisions that are based upon the use of software but not on robo-advisors or artificial intelligence.

Differentiating between a robo-advisor and financial bot or chatbot

Of course, we must differentiate between a robo-advisor and financial bot or chatbot. The latter are software designed to understand natural language and perform simple actions like transferring money between your accounts. Robo-advisors, for their part, are more sophisticated tools intended to provide financial and investment advice or even trade financial assets on your behalf. Nonetheless, they lack the real artificial intelligence to make decisions instead of you and outside their programmed actions. Thus, you should take with a pinch of salt the claims of pundits that say robo-advisors will disrupt the entire financial industry, running in the cloud and providing financial guidance for everyone.

Sure, a robo-advisor can easily spot trading signals its creators have coded into it – buy and sell, high and low, etc. but it lacks the logic and the impulsive behavior of people. All financial markets are driven largely by the market mood i.e. rumors about a certain corporation or pending decision of the Federal Reserve. A robot cannot understand rumors even if it has been developed to understand natural language to a certain degree. No software developer is currently able to design a robo-advisor that could digest a rumor like… “Yesterday, the president of XYZ Inc. was caught with his lassie…” A trader on the floor of NYSE will immediately deduct that shareholder who will not be happy. How will a robo-advisor act in such a situation is still a mystery.

Yes, a robo-advisor or a bot can be very useful in automated trading based on trading signals. Can such a tool develop an investment strategy, though? No way, at least for the foreseeable future. MyKAI by Kasisto is a mix of robo-advisor and chatbot that got much attention recently but it is not able to handle complex banking and finance transactions, too. It can learn based on user actions and transactions history but in fact it replaces a personal visit to your bank being unable to develop and perform a complex financial strategy.

Combining both Robo-advisors & Humans

You cannot rely on a robo-advisor to take strategic decisions about investments, transactions, or business development. However, you can rely on chatbots and robo-advisors to perform basic support and maintenance actions and take care of your financial accounts. For good or for bad, you should still consult with a human about your investments or make any strategic financial decision yourself.

By Kiril Kirilov

Episode 3: The Bottomless Cloud – An Interview with David Friend of Wasabi

Why data is not “the new oil” and why “cloud” means more than we think ...

Episode 5: How the Pandemic is Changing Business and the Cloud

An Interview with Ed Dryer of Steadfast With the global pandemic wreaking havoc on business ...

Episode 2: Coronavirus Phishing Emails and Work-from-Home Meetings

Coronavirus Phishing Emails What to watch out for as scammers exploit pandemic panic, and tips ...
Patrick Joggerst

Living on the Edge: The New Real-Time Communications Security Risks

Real-time communications Security Risks As more and more people have been forced to work remotely due to the global public health crisis, collaboration platforms have ...
Kokumai

Identity Assurance – Sufficient and Necessary Conditions

Identity Assurance It is not easy to define the 'sufficient condition' for describing a set of processes used to establish that a natural person is ...
Google Prog

Working with security researchers to make the web safer for everyone

Working with security researchers What do a 19-year-old researcher from Uruguay, a restaurant owner from Cluj, Romania and a Cambridge professor have in common? They’re ...
Kayla Matthews

6 Reasons More Organizations Are Adopting Zero Trust

Organizations Adopting Zero Trust The zero trust model is becoming more commonplace in security. It's based on the realization that threats exist inside and outside ...
Patrick Joggerst

From Virtualization to Cloudification: Transforming Networks, Now What?

Virtualization to Cloudification As we head into the next decade of telecommunications network technology transformation, we find ourselves at a pivotal moment as the era ...
Medical

5 Realtime Coronavirus (COVID-19) Tracking Maps using Big Data

Coronavirus Realtime Tracking Maps We are living in a pandemic world. As of March 12th, 2020 the Director-General of the World Health Organization (WHO) Dr ...
Martin Mendelsohn

New Executive Roles in the Post-Corona Era

Executive Roles in the Post-Corona Era As the global economy shows early signs of reviving from past months of rigormortis, forward-looking companies will be busy ...
Hillary T

The Current Wave of Smart Home Technology

The Future of Smart Home Technology Some say the vision of smart homes kicked off with the invention of household machines in the early part ...
Signal Messenger: How to Successfully Resist Wiretapping Attempts

Signal Messenger: How to Successfully Resist Wiretapping Attempts

Successfully Resist Wiretapping Attempts Against the backdrop of events in the US, the popularity of the Signal secure messenger has grown sharply - from 6,000 ...
Kokumai

History, Current Status and Future Scenarios of Expanded Password System

Future Scenarios of Expanded Password System Passwords are so hard to manage that some people are urging the removal of passwords from digital identity altogether. What ...