CLOUDTWEAKS CONTRIBUTOR PROGRAM

Join the CloudTweaks thought leadership contributor program which includes a customized profile, branded identity page, newsletter marketing, social amplification and more...

The program is currently available to consultants, influencers or executive level contributors.

Biometric Authentication

Passwords: More Secure Than Biometric Authentication?

Biometric Authentication

Biometrics has long granted or denied access to secure things like premises and vehicles. Now it is being seriously considered for the same role as regards connected services. A recent draft publication by the US Department of Commerce National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) proposes guidelines for reliable digital identity management including biometric authentication for granting access to diverse services through a dedicated device.

The draft is provoking a far-reaching debate. This centres on two factor authentication and authorisation. NIST argues there are circumstances when authentication via biometric device alone is sufficient. Others argue for supplementary or alternative authentication. The NIST proposal follows a simple logic: devices and accompanying password or PIN are “something you have.” Their ownership and your password memorisation itself serves as valid secondary authentication.

The draft proposes the following procedures for one time password devices (OTP devices): “The OTP is displayed on the device and manually input to the verifier. For example, an OTP device may display 6 characters at a time, thereby proving possession and control of the device. The multi-factor OTP device is something you have, and it SHALL be activated by either something you know or something you are.

All very good, but that “something you have” might turn out to be biometric data which is not secret at all. And passwords can be stolen or compromised in plentiful ways. Thus, one can flummox face recognition simply by taking or downloading someone else’s mugshot. And anyone can take one’s fingerprints from an object one has handled. Iris patterns can be captured by high resolution cameras. Et cetera…

The proposed solution is attack detection (PAD) technology. Liveness detection, for example, detects whether someone requesting access through a biometric device is actually a real person. But it still leaves plenty to be desired. Other factors that affect biometric authentication include a myriad of unpredictable events like a user injuring their enrolled fingers, experiencing changing facial features or body weight, iris recognition failing after eye surgery, and all the rest of it.

Hence, NIST concludes, an alternative authentication method is required and users must be able to use a second factor in the form of a memorised secret. This returns us to the good old password or secret question. This in turn ushers in wider questions on whether two-factor authentication is indeed secure and reliable, and whether biometrics in particular can be trusted.

The broader scenario usually involves sending confirmation messages to mobile devices. Physical or other coercion scenarios aside, one would need only occasional access to a mobile to complete compromised authentications involving PIN codes or passwords. Experts believe biometric authentication is good for physical security but impairs security provided by passwords. Sometimes, a false sense of security is worse than no security at all.

Many security experts argue that fallback password provide an extra layer of security. This pertains especially to cases when biometric authentication fails for false reasons. Others argue that where these two authentication methods work in parallel, not simultaneously, they in fact result in less secure authentication.

Hitoshi Kokumai is a long time advocate of either biometrics or passwords as sole authentication factors. He advises biometric product users to turn off biometrics functionality when their devices also allow passwords. His argument is that the convenience of biometrics with passwords as a fallback only obtains when users can accept lower security.

Biometrics used with a fallback password, the most common and popular way of deploying biometrics, might be helpful where convenience matters. But it is wrong to claim that it helps for security. Biometrics should be turned off where security matters. Password/PIN-only authentication is more secure.

Some people advocate a password-less life, perhaps without thinking about its consequence; life in a democratic society must secure the right for individuals not to get their identity authenticated without their knowledgeable confirmation. This volitional process can be achieved only by “volitional” identity authentication involving memorized secrets (passwords).

Due respect should be paid to the value of the biometric solutions as an effective “body identification” tool for forensic and the likes of border control. But it is not wise to use it for “identity authentication” in cyberspace,” Kokumai told CloudTweaks.

There is no doubt that biometric authentication offers convenient access to, say, a ‘phone. Access to critical services and locations is another matter. Biometric data is all too easy to obtain. Passwords are also hackable. What we probably have to admit is that we do not yet possess a technology which is fully compromise proof. This puts biometric authentication very much under question when it comes to business or organisation level security. A cautious approach remains the best attitude to a technology that demonstrably has a long way to go before offering truly secure identification.

By Kiril V Kirilov

Kiril Kirilov

Kiril V. Kirilov is a content strategist and writer who is analyzing the intersection of business and IT for nearly two decades. Some of the topics he covers include SaaS, cloud computing, artificial intelligence, machine learning, IT startup funding, autonomous vehicles and all things technology. He is also an author of a book about the future of AI and BIg Data in marketing.

The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Birds & The Bees
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - The Wish List
Comic
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Keys To The Car
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Drone Competition
Infosec thought leaders

Cryptocurrencies and Ransomware: How VDI Can Help Defend Against the Next Ransomware Attack

Cryptocurrencies and Ransomware The WannaCry ransomware made headlines back in May when it crippled hospitals across the UK and put ...
Critical Success Factors when shifting Workloads into the Cloud

Critical Success Factors when shifting Workloads into the Cloud

Shifting Workloads into the Cloud By 2020, 92 percent of all workloads will reside in the cloud. Yet challenges remain ...
Open APIs Alone Won’t Change Banking

Open APIs Alone Won’t Change Banking

Open Banking API's Most people think of banks as one monolithic entity, but they are actually made up of hundreds ...
Want to dip your toe into the cloud? Challenges of a Large Migration

Want to dip your toe into the cloud? Challenges of a Large Migration

Challenges of a Large Migration Migrating to the cloud can be a daunting task. First you have to go through ...
Built to Last: Choosing the Right Infrastructure Partner for Your Game

Built to Last: Choosing the Right Infrastructure Partner for Your Game

Choosing the Right Infrastructure Partner There are millions of gamers around the globe, and according to gaming market research firm ...
The Democratization of Business Software Technology

The Democratization of Business Software Technology

Democratization of Software Advances in the cloud have changed the way we interact with the world. From how we pay ...
Imminent IoT Eye-Tracking Technologies To Transform The Connected World

Imminent IoT Eye-Tracking Technologies To Transform The Connected World

IoT Eye Tracking Smelling may be the first of the perceptible senses, but the eye is the fastest moving organ ...
real time hacking attacks

Live Real Time Hacking and Ransomware Tracking Maps Online

Real Time Hacking Attacks We've recently covered a few real time hacking maps but have decided to extend the list based on the recent ransomware activities with some additional real time hacking attack and ransomware tracking maps. Ransomware refers to malicious ...
Cloud Migration – 10 ‘Do it Right’ Tips

Cloud Migration – 10 ‘Do it Right’ Tips

Cloud Migration Tips Businesses continue to adopt the cloud at break neck speed. Inherent benefits like lower operational costs, no infrastructure overheads, and quick access to better technology make cloud a very attractive proposition for businesses, especially start-ups and SMEs ...
Business Analytics Vs Data Science

Business Analytics Vs Data Science

Big Data Continues To Grow Big Data continues to be a much discussed topic of interest and for good reason.  According to a recent report from International Data Corporation (IDC), "worldwide revenues for big data and business analytics will grow ...
Load Testing Tools

Load Testing Tools

Provided is a short list of load testing tools which will test server and application resistance and certainly valuable in order to help test and tweak your company's infrastructure ...
Gartner’s Top 10 Predictions For IT In 2018 And Beyond

Gartner’s Top 10 Predictions For IT In 2018 And Beyond

Gartner’s Top 10 Predictions For IT In 2018 In 2020, AI will become a positive net job motivator, creating 2.3M jobs while eliminating only 1.8M jobs. By 2020, IoT technology will be in 95% of electronics for new product designs ...