John Pientka

Academia is on the Ropes but is Reluctant to Change. Why are Most of Them Digital Dinosaurs?

Moving a university is like moving a cemetery—you can’t expect any help from the inhabitants,” says Barb Oakley, Ph.D. Higher Educations’ product is too expensive, takes too long and doesn’t produce enough of the graduates needed. New technology could be transformative, but…

The ugly truth: at most public universities, only 19 percent of full-time students earn a bachelor’s degree in four years. Even at state flagship universities only 36 percent of full-time students complete their bachelor’s degree on time. To make the numbers look better educators have moved the goal posts to now show how many graduate within six years.

Great! Now the students and their families are even deeper in debt. Total student loans clock in at $1.45 Trillion. That’s more than all the credit card debt held in the U.S. and almost 5 million student borrowers are delinquent. It’s no wonder that society is questioning whether so-called higher education is worth it.

And the bad news keeps on coming. Forget AI taking jobs. We cannot pump out enough degree holders for the openings there are. Take the critical area of STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Math) upon which our modern world is so dependent. There were only 30,835 STEM graduates to fill the 230,246 additional STEM jobs from 2014-2015. That’s a shortfall of almost 87% in this key area.

What the hell is going on? Listen to what Larry Summers, the economist and ex-president of Harvard had to say: “Not enough people are innovating enough in higher education. General Electric looks nothing like it looked in 1975. Harvard, Yale, Princeton, or Stanford look a lot like they looked in 1975.”

It’s not like there is a shortage of technologies that can make the university experience more productive, rewarding and efficient. MOOC’s (Massive Open Online Courses) pioneered the concept of challenging the traditional lecture model. These online courses can be even better than the traditional lecture because they more effectively deal with the way humans actually learn.

Too hard to abandon the traditional college lecture altogether? Worried that social interaction is also part of the learning experience? How about flipping things on their head. The chalk talk part of the lecture is packaged in more digestible video for pre consumption and the lecture time is devoted to interaction, Q&A, etc.

How do we make the learning experience more personal? I can remember sitting in a 600 student lecturing hall and then struggling to wrestle with the material and my questions because my TA (Teaching Assistant) spoke poor English. Georgia Tech may have hit on the way to address this need for personalization. It has a very well known and increasingly popular online master’s in computer science. (BTW, talk about cost–effectiveness, this online degree costs $7,000. The very same in-person degree is $25,000 for GA residents and $60,000 for non-residents.)

It’s so popular that Ashok Goel, the lead professor in a course on AI, can’t deliver the personal experience he knows students deserve because he can’t leverage his TA’s far enough. His insight: most teachers know that most students ask the same questions year after year as they come to terms with the material. Doctor Goel thought why not build an AI to help.

The result was Jill Watson (yep, the “Watson” of Jeopardy fame). “She” was so successful that most students did not know “she” was not human. Imagine how this could work for all those foundation courses that are required of all students, which tenured faculty hates to teach and adjunct professors are stuck with grinding out their delivery. You could have a rock star professor record an on-line set of video lectures and an AI handle most of the student interactions.

And there is much, much more. Even the mind numbing, obtuse textbook can be subject to digital magic turning it into a lively compelling teaching instrument that is more like “education software” than just text. With all these exciting options, higher education could seem ripe for some disruption, right? Not so fast. All these examples are notable because they are rare.

The inmates run the asylum. A recent report on digital transformation in higher education, only 50% of respondents (including students, university leaders, and education technology company founders) expect the traditional university “model” to be disrupted by 2025.

Given the nature of human institutions we should not be surprised. Inertia is a powerful drag on the advent of the new. However, there are some pretty powerful forces at work. Costs are too high. Society demands for talent are not being met. And, maybe most importantly, each year the oncoming cohort of students are more and more tech saving and demanding. When do you think it will be academia’s Kodak moment?

By John Pientka

John Pientka

John is currently the principal of Pientka and Associates which specializes in IT and Cloud Computing.

Over the years John has been vice president at CGI Federal, where he lead their cloud computing division. He founded and served as CEO of GigEpath, which provided communication solutions to major corporations. He has also served as president of British Telecom’s outsourcing arm Syncordia, vice president and general manager of a division at Motorola.

John has earned his M.B.A. from Harvard University as well as a bachelor’s degree from the State University in Buffalo, New York.

View Website
ThreatMetrix Quarterly Fintech Cybercrime Report 2017

ThreatMetrix Quarterly Fintech Cybercrime Report 2017

Fintech Cybercrime Report 2017 ThreatMetrix has released its latest quarterly cybercrime report based on cybercrime attacks from October to December 2016, detailing trends across financial services and eCommerce, with a global study of traffic patterns ...
Protect Against Network Failures

Five Things Organizations Can Do To Protect Against Network Failures

Protect Against Network Failures It is no surprise that whenever there is an outage in a public or private cloud, organizations lose business, face the wrath of angry customers and take a hit on their ...
RSA Conference: FUD-free or filled?

RSA Conference: FUD-free or filled?

IoT 15 Billion Units By 2021 At the annual RSA conference, there were plenty of discussions and presentations on the evolving cybersecurity threat landscape, including application security issues, the internet of things (IoT) and data ...
Understanding Cloud Pricing Models

Trends in MarTech to Look Out for This Year

Trends in MarTech Marketing technology, or MarTech, has come a long way with a landscape that is steadily growing. In 2016, the MarTech landscape has nearly doubled in size, with no signs of stopping. The ...
Part 2: Strategies for Securing Mobile Devices in a Cloud-based World

Part 2: Strategies for Securing Mobile Devices in a Cloud-based World

Part 2: Strategies for Securing Mobile Devices With workplace mobility now a way of life and companies investing in cloud-based apps more than ever, security is moving beyond the four walls. Just a few years ...
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - The Letter "G"
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Checking It Twice
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - The Backup Reminder
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - YTF
Star Wars IoT CES
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Dial-up Speeds
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Once A Year
CloudTweaks Comic
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Easter Egg Hunt


Rackspace Launches Kubernetes-as-a-Service with Fully Managed Operations

Rackspace Launches Kubernetes-as-a-Service with Fully Managed Operations

SAN ANTONIO – May 16, 2018 – Rackspace today announced Rackspace Kubernetes-as-a-Service, a highly-available managed service that transforms the way enterprises can utilize new container technologies, accelerating their digital transformation. Rackspace is focused on delivering true transformation ...
Artificial Intelligence to Add US$182 Billion to UAE Economy by 2035, Accenture Research Shows

Artificial Intelligence to Add US$182 Billion to UAE Economy by 2035, Accenture Research Shows

Financial services, healthcare, and transport and storage industries likely to see the biggest gains DUBAI, United Arab Emirates; May 21, 2018 – Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to boost economic growth in the United ...
Facebook suspends 200 apps over data misuse investigation

Facebook suspends 200 apps over data misuse investigation

(Reuters) - Facebook Inc has so far suspended around 200 apps in the first stage of its review into apps that had access to large quantities of user data, in a response to a scandal ...