The Tolly Group Report: How Dimension Data Beat Out Some Big Players

The Tolly Group Report: How Dimension Data Beat Out Some Big Players

The Tolly Group Report: How Dimension Data beat out some big players to help keep your data up to date

(Update Revision: Initial Post, August 30th)

The next time you check out busy commercial websites – those, for example, that talk about products, sell them, ship them and generate buzz and conversation about them, spare a thought for all of the billions of bits of data running around behind the scenes to make these sites’ videos, promos and “buy now” catalogues work smoothly, reliably and securely. Much of the infrastructure behind sites like these comes to you courtesy of a few organizations that have recognized the need for a more cohesive approach to collection and redistribution of data on the cloud, through the use of a “network-centric,” rather than “best effort” structure.

The technological wizardry behind complex websites tends to go unnoticed by the average consumer; at least until something goes wrong, at which point the great “fail whale” emerges to spoil the fun.

The cloud is growing by leaps and bounds, but a great deal of the infrastructure is built on existing components. It can often be a hodgepodge of servers and programs built using elements that were not always designed to scale up to the degree and with the versatility currently required. “Cloud” may exist at the top of every CIO’s agenda, but, according to Gartner Research, it still forms a relatively small portion of the 3.7 trillion dollar IT industry.

This means we are still in the early days of the cloud as a primary technology. It has a way to go to emerge as a platform for more than just testing and development, and to become the place for hosting mission-critical data applications.

Enter the Tolly Group.

The Tolly Group was founded in 1989 to provide hands-on evaluation and certification of IT products and services. In a recent study, conducted in May 2013, Tolly researchers tested the cloud performance of some major providers: Amazon, Rackspace, IBM and Dimension Data in all four areas: CPU, RAM, storage and network performance. Their findings exposed the price and performance limitations of today’s “commodity” or “best effort” clouds that rely on traditional, server-centric architectures. The report found that of these four big players, the network-centric approach used by Dimension Data’s enterprise-class cloud helped lower cost and risk, and accelerate migration of mission-critical apps to the cloud.

keao-caindec

Keao Caindec, CMO of the Cloud Solutions Business for Dimension Data was obviously pleased with the results of Tolly’s stringent testing, but not surprised. He points out that the report tells an interesting story. He says it shows how not all clouds are created equal, and that there is a big difference between providers. This, he believes, will force end-users to look more critically at underlying performance of any provider they choose to do business with.

As an example, Caindec points out that when someone goes and buys a router switch or server, these pieces come with specs.  But such specs don’t exist broadly in the cloud world. In many cases, he says, clouds were developed as low cost compute platforms – a best effort. Now, however, this is not enough. A provider must demonstrate a great deal more reliability in terms of speed, security and scalability – for example, designing an application to scale either up or out. When scaling up, a provider must be able to add more power to the cloud server. When scaling out, it must be able to easily add more instances. He points out that clients in a growth phase must be careful about scaling up, since such expansions may not lead to the desired level increased performance.

Caindec points to some specific types of work that Dimension Data does with its high-profile clients: “We help them with their websites by leveraging the public cloud for testing and development. This allows granular configuration of the server, which means that each server is configured with as much storage/power as is needed.” He points out that customers often need to make sure they are not buying too much of one resource. For example a database app needs lots of memory, maybe 32 Gig of memory on a server, but not necessarily a lot of computing power. Dimension Data, he says, takes care to help clients to configure exact amount of resources necessary, allowing them to save money by not over-provisioning.

Caindec finds the Tolly study to be eye-opening primarily because it begs the question: are low cost clouds really low cost? “If the model is more best effort and because of that you have to run more servers, are you being as economical as you could?” For the most part, he points out, the costs of cloud providers are similar. But performance levels vary much more dramatically. In other words, “You may not be saving all the money you could. You may find a lower cost per hour, but in a larger environment, especially when running thousands of servers, this does not become economic.”

Caindec points out that at this point in IT history there is still a great deal that is not well understood. There are not a lot of statistics. He hopes that IT managers and CTOs everywhere will be able to obtain more granular insights from the full Tolly Report. Insights such as the fact that more memory does not mean applications will run better or provide better throughput. “If you scale up the size of the server, the server runs faster, but requires higher throughput to reach other servers.” He says companies must be careful to benchmark their own applications. It is not necessary to hire a high-profile testing firm like Tolly to do this, however; testing tools are available publicly, but he strongly advises more testing and awareness as standard practice.

By Steve Prentice

About Steve Prentice

Steve Prentice is a project manager, writer, speaker and expert on productivity in the workplace, specifically the juncture where people and technology intersect. He is a senior writer for CloudTweaks.

Find out more
View All Articles

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.

Comic
Using Cloud Technology In The Education Industry

Using Cloud Technology In The Education Industry

Education Tech and the Cloud Arguably one of society’s most important functions, teaching can still seem antiquated at times. Many schools still function similarly to how they did five or 10 years ago, which is surprising considering the amount of technical innovation we’ve seen in the past decade. Education is an industry ripe for innovation…

5% Of Companies Have Embraced The Digital Innovation Fostered By Cloud Computing

5% Of Companies Have Embraced The Digital Innovation Fostered By Cloud Computing

Embracing The Cloud We love the stories of big complacent industry leaders having their positions sledge hammered by nimble cloud-based competitors. Saleforce.com chews up Oracle’s CRM business. Airbnb has a bigger market cap than Marriott. Amazon crushes Walmart (and pretty much every other retailer). We say: “How could they have not seen this coming?” But, more…

What Futuristic Tech Will You See In Your Lifetime?

What Futuristic Tech Will You See In Your Lifetime?

Futuristic Tech The world and what people can do is increasingly being driven by technology. It has already shaped the world we live in, but over the next few decades it is set to shape the world in ways that we can barely imagine. There have already been some great leaps in IoT technology recently,…

The Lighter Side Of The Cloud – Hiding Spots

The Lighter Side Of The Cloud – Hiding Spots

By David Fletcher Please feel free to share our comics via social media networks such as Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, Pinterest. Clear attribution (Twitter example: via@cloudtweaks) to our original comic sources is greatly appreciated.

Recent Articles - Posted by
Fintech Exploiting AI and Blockchain Technology

Fintech Exploiting AI and Blockchain Technology

AI and Blockchain Technology The field of artificial intelligence (AI) had progressed rapidly in the last ten years, though first recognized in the 1950s. From autonomous motor vehicles to digital personal assistants, the technology is making its way into a variety of industries, enabling better task automation, language processing, and data analytics. But more recently,…

Cloud Services Providers – Learning To Keep The Lights On

Cloud Services Providers – Learning To Keep The Lights On

The True Meaning of Availability What is real availability? In our line of work, cloud service providers approach availability from the inside out. And in many cases, some never make it past their own front door given how challenging it is to keep the lights on at home let alone factors that are out of…

Your Biggest Data Security Threat Could Be….

Your Biggest Data Security Threat Could Be….

Paying Attention To Data Security Your biggest data security threat could be sitting next to you… Data security is a big concern for businesses. The repercussions of a data security breach ranges from embarrassment, to costly lawsuits and clean-up jobs – particularly when confidential client information is involved. But although more and more businesses are…

5 Ways To Ensure Your Cloud Solution Is Always Operational

5 Ways To Ensure Your Cloud Solution Is Always Operational

Ensure Your Cloud Is Always Operational We have become so accustomed to being online that we take for granted the technological advances that enable us to have instant access to everything and anything on the internet, wherever we are. In fact, it would likely be a little disconcerting if we really mapped out all that…

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

Choosing IaaS or a Cloud-Enabled Managed Hosting Provider?

There is a Difference – So Stop Comparing We are all familiar with the old saying “That’s like comparing apples to oranges” and though we learned this lesson during our early years we somehow seem to discount this idiom when discussing the Cloud. Specifically, IT buyers often feel justified when comparing the cost of a…

Using Cloud Technology In The Education Industry

Using Cloud Technology In The Education Industry

Education Tech and the Cloud Arguably one of society’s most important functions, teaching can still seem antiquated at times. Many schools still function similarly to how they did five or 10 years ago, which is surprising considering the amount of technical innovation we’ve seen in the past decade. Education is an industry ripe for innovation…

Cloud Computing Myths That SMBs Should Know

Cloud Computing Myths That SMBs Should Know

Cloud Computing and SMBs Cloud Computing is the hottest issue among IT intellects of Small and Medium Businesses (SMBs). Like any other computer-orientated technology, Cloud Computing has some misconceptions and myths that often kick-start arguments among the two opposing groups: Cloud Supporters and Cloud Opponents. Both of these groups have their own ideology and reasons…

Using Big Data To Make Cities Smarter

Using Big Data To Make Cities Smarter

Using Big Data To Make Cities Smarter The city of the future is impeccably documented. Sensors are used to measure air quality, traffic patterns, and crowd movement. Emerging neighborhoods are quickly recognized, public safety threats are found via social networks, and emergencies are dealt with quicklier. Crowdsourcing reduces commuting times, provides people with better transportation…

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations

Unusual Clandestine Cloud Data Centre Service Locations Everyone knows what the cloud is, but does everybody know where the cloud is? We try to answer that as we look at some of the most unusual data centre locations in the world. Under the Eyes of a Deity Deep beneath the famous Uspenski Cathedral in the…

The Storytelling Machine: Big Content and Big Data

The Storytelling Machine: Big Content and Big Data

Bridging The Gap Between Big Content and Big Data Advances in cloud computing, along with the big data movement, have transformed the business IT landscape. Leveraging the cloud, companies are now afforded on demand capacity and mobile accessibility to their business-critical systems and information. At the same time, the amount of structured and unstructured data…

Cloud Infographic: The Future of File Storage

Cloud Infographic: The Future of File Storage

 The Future of File Storage A multi-billion dollar market Data storage has been readily increasing for decades. In 1989, an 8MB Macintosh Portable was top of the range; in 2006, the Dell Inspiron 6400 became available, boasting 160GB; and now, we have the ‘Next Generation’ MacBook Pro with 256GB of storage built in. But, of course,…

Why Small Businesses Need A Business Intelligence Dashboard

Why Small Businesses Need A Business Intelligence Dashboard

The Business Intelligence Dashboard As a small business owner you would certainly know the importance of collecting and analyzing data pertaining to your business and transactions. Business Intelligence dashboards allow not only experts but you also to access information generated by analysis of data through a convenient display. Anyone in the company can have access…