Controversial Cybersecurity Bill A Threat To Privacy

Controversial Cybersecurity Bill

As the US Senate prepares to vote on the controversial Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act just days before the August recess, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has warned that the privacy of US citizens and organizations may be compromised. The DHS has also warned that the proposed legislation might slow down response to cyber attacks, and therefore be counter productive.

Additionally, a number of IT firms and privacy advocates are convinced that the proposed legislation will make it much easier for the National Security Agency (NSA) to acquire corporate and personal information that it not related to cybersecurity.

The new cybersecurity bill aims to create incentives that will encourage companies to share information of cyber threats with the federal government, and has generally been welcomed. But potential threats to privacy and other issues could stall implementation of the legislation until next year, because there simply isn’t enough time to debate issues before the upcoming recess at the end of this week.

Privacy Threats

An active privacy advocate, Senator Al Franken (Democrat) has made public a letter to him from the deputy secretary of the DHS, Alejandro Mayorkas that indicates if the bill is passed in its current form, it could undermine the cybersecurity objectives of the nation as a whole. It would also threaten “important privacy protections and civil liberties.”

Senator Bernie Sanders (Democrat), who is running for president, has proposed an amendment to the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act (CISA) that will establish a group that will investigate the implications relating to privacy and how data gathered might be used. Essentially he wants transparency for consumers and for Government because of the real threat of modern technology on the privacy of Americans. His argument is that public policy has been outpaced by technology, and already “a huge amount of information” is being collected about individuals from where they go to what they do.

Also an active advocate for the individual right to privacy, Sanders voted against the USA Freedom Act earlier this year, because he said it did not safeguard privacy. Amongst other things, the legislation, enacted in June this year, “reformed” the way federal government conducts electronic surveillance, uses trap and trace devices, gathers information for counter-terrorism, foreign intelligence and criminal purposes, and accesses business records.

Two other senators, Dianne Feinstein (Democrat) and Richard Burr (Republican), have also proposed changes to the bill that will limit what government can do with information shared. For example, they say it should only be used for cybersecurity purposes and not to prosecute criminals, even in the case of “serious violent felonies.”

Calls to Pass the Bill Immediately

This is the third time a cybersecurity bill of this type has been presented to the Senate. To prevent it being stalled a third time, the US Chamber of Commerce – a very influential body – has urged “every member” to pass the Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act of 2015 immediately. When the bill was approved by the Senate’s Intelligence Committee in March this year there was only one vote against it – that of Senator Ron Wyden (Democrat) who continues to push for amendments before it becomes law.

Mitch McConnell, Senate Majority Leader (Republican) has also urged senators to pass the bill immediately.

If the bill is passed this week, it will still need to be “reconciled” with cybersecurity bill passed by the House of Representatives in April. Only then can it sent to President Barack Obama for signing into law.

By Penny Swift

Episode 5: How the Pandemic is Changing Business and the Cloud

An Interview with Ed Dryer of Steadfast With the global pandemic wreaking havoc on business ...

Episode 1: Why Small and Medium Sized Businesses Need an MSP

Small and Medium Sized Businesses Need an MSP Small and medium-sized businesses don’t enjoy the ...

Episode 6: Cloud Migration: Why It’s More Important Than Ever

The Importance of Cloud Migration Moving fully to the cloud is still a concern for ...
Anita Raj

Will there be a normal to go back to after COVID-19?

The COVID-19 Aftermath Until November last year, not one of us would have expected life to take such a dramatic turn in as short as ...
Patrick Joggerst

Session Border Control as a Service: Faster, More Secure and Dramatically Less Complex Enterprise Communications

Session Border Control as a Service As businesses are increasingly moving to cloud-based unified communications (UC) for improved collaboration and productivity, they must also ensure ...
David Shearer

Looking Back – and Looking Forward to 2020

As we celebrate our thirtieth anniversary here at (ISC)², it’s incredible to look back at the changes our industry has been through. From advances in ...
Brian Day

Tips for Developing Apps In a Cloud Environment

DevOps and the Cloud Unless you’ve just started a brand-new organization, your IT environment is currently running a diverse collection of last-generation and older applications ...
Marty

Digital Transformation: Adapting Your Business Online

The Age of Digital Transformation There is little doubt that the transition to cloud computing is driving an insatiable demand for digital transformation. Countless organizations ...
Hacker Cloud

Pandemic and Cybersecurity: Top Threats to Businesses

Pandemic and Cybersecurity The worldwide spread of the COVID-19 virus is coming to naught (or at least we hope so). But the impact that this ...
Sergey lypchenko 

The Top 7 Latest DevOps Trends to Follow

DevOps Trends to Follow Awareness of the latest DevOps trends is important for companies which consider the integration of DevOps into their development processes as ...
Kip Compton

What’s Ahead for Cloud in 2019

The Cloud In 2019 2018 was an incredible time for cloud. Its impact on customer experiences, business processes and models, and workforce innovations was undeniable ...
Mark Barrenechea

Security is Job 1: Machines vs. Machines

Digital is redefining cybercrime and cyberwarfare Cyberattacks today are multi-stage, hard to discover and highly targeted. Some security threats are accidental, stemming from unauthorized employee ...
Bigcommerce

Magento 1 Is Nearing Its End – Is It Time To Migrate To BigCommerce?

Time To Migrate To BigCommerce? Nearly three years ago, Magento declared that they would be ending support for their Magento 1 software. All versions of ...