hitoshi

The ID Federation: What Technology Can Displace The Password?

The Future Password

Many people shout that the password is dead or should be killed dead. The password could be killed, however, only when there is an alternative to the password. Let us think about what technology can displace the password.

Some people might say that multi-factor authentications or ID federations will do it. It is not easy, however, to conceive that the password can be displaced by multi-factor schemes for which one of the factors is a password or ID federations which require a reliable password as the master-password.

Some might say “Not using any password altogether is the way to kill the password dead”. Yes, I have to admit, the password could then be killed dead entirely, but it would be criminals rather than us that will be the beneficiaries of such password-free cyber space. In a world where we live without remembered passwords, i.e., where our identity is established without our volitional participation, we would be able to have a safe sleep only when we are alone in a firmly locked room. It would be a Utopia for criminals and a Dystopia for most of us.

shutterstock_379201975

Some might say “PIN can”. This observation would, however, only lead us to the entrance to Alice’s Wonderland. If a PIN that is a weak form of numbers-only password could displace the password, a puppy should be able to displace the dog, a kitten the cat, a cub the lion.

Many are saying “Biometrics can”. This observation would lead us to another entrance to Alice’s Wonderland. Biometric solutions used in cyber space need a password (fallback password) registered in case of false rejection. If “something” which has to rely on“the other thing” could displace “the other thing”, your foot should be able to displace your leg for walking. Alice’s Wonderland might receive it, but I have huge difficulties in imagining what it could look like in this 4D Space-Time universe.

There are a lot of people who take it for granted that the password can be displaced by the biometrics operated in cyberspace together with a fallback password. How could such a misconception happen?

Blind Spot in Our Mind

Let us imagine that we are watching two models of smart phones – Model A with Pincode and Model B with Pincode and Fingerprint Scan. Which of the two models do you think is securer?

  • when you hear that Model A is protected by Pincode while Model B is protected by both Pincode and Fingerprints
  • when you hear that Model A can be unlocked by Pincode while Model B can be unlocked by both

Pincode and Fingerprints

  •  when you hear that Model A can be attacked only by Pincode while Model B can be attacked by both Pincode and Fingerprints

Is your observation the same for all the 3 situations?

Eye-Opening Experience

Now let us imagine that there are two houses – (1) with one entrance and (2) with two entrances placed in parallel. Which house is safer against burglars? Every one of us will agree that the answer is plainly (1). Nobody would dare to allege that (2) is safer because it is protected by two entrances. Similarly, the login by a Pincode/password alone is securer than the login by a biometric sensor backed up by a fallback Pincode/password.

Debates over Backdoor between Apple vs FBI

It appears that something crucial is overlooked in the heated debates about the backdoor on smartphones, which is the focus point of the recent events with Apple and the FBI that have drawn a lot of attention worldwide.

I would like to point out that there already exists a backdoor on many of the latest smartphones, namely, a fingerprint scanner or a set of camera and software for capturing faces, irises and other body features which are easily collected from the unyielding, sleeping, unconscious and dead people.

As the technologies of sensing biometric features advance, so do the technologies of copying and replaying them. None of body temperature, movement, pulse and brainwave can be exceptions. Biometrics could be great technologies for forensic and physical security, but far from valid for identity assurance in cyber space.

Suggestions

As analysed above, the authentication by biometrics in cyber space comes with poorer security than Pincode/password-only authentication in most cases. A false sense of security is often worse than the lack of security. I would like to put forward the suggestions below.

  • The vendors of those smart devices, who are conscious of privacy and security of consumers, could tell the consumers not to turn on the biometric functions.
  • Consumers, who are concerned about their privacy and security, could refrain from activating the biometric backdoors.
  • The deployment of biometric solutions could instead be recommended where consumers can accept “below-one” factor authentication in return for better convenience as the case may be.

By Hitoshi Kokumai

Hitoshi Kokumai

President, Mnemonic Security, Inc. Hitoshi has been studying and writing about cyber security for a number of years. You can see his work on many leading online technology publications.

View Website

Hitoshi is the Founder of Mnemonic Security, Inc. He has been studying and writing about cyber security for several years and his work has appeared in a number of security related publications.

How Adversaries Are Refining and Improving Ransomware in 2017

How Adversaries Are Refining and Improving Ransomware in 2017

Improving Ransomware in 2017 Once adversaries have found a method for breaching network defenses, stealing data, or otherwise generating revenue, they’ll continue to refine these tactics to avoid detection and improve effectiveness. Ransomware, one of ...
Organizational Transformation: Taking The DevOps Dive

Organizational Transformation: Taking The DevOps Dive

Taking The DevOps Dive The Gartner IT Glossary defines DevOps as “…a change in IT culture, focusing on rapid IT service delivery through the adoption of agile, lean practices in the context of a system-oriented approach. DevOps ...
Business Intelligence And Analytics In The Cloud, 2017

Business Intelligence And Analytics In The Cloud, 2017

Business Intelligence In The Cloud, 2017 78% are planning to increase the use of cloud for BI and data management in the next twelve months. 46% of organizations prefer public cloud platforms for cloud BI, ...
Get Used To It – Artificial Intelligence For Real-time Gas Pricing

Get Used To It – Artificial Intelligence For Real-time Gas Pricing

Real-time Gas Pricing Get used to it – we will extract every dollar you can afford at your friendly …. ! I was reading in the Wall Street Journal about the implementation of Artificial Intelligence ...
Cloud Advances One Funeral at a Time

Cloud Advances One Funeral at a Time

The Advancing Cloud Forecasts scream huge growth rates for cloud but in the big picture it is tiny. Max Planck noted: “Science advances one funeral at a time.” Is cloud the same? The demand for ...
startup tech comic series
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Security Overkill
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Playing It Safe
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Car Troubles
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - F96qL#5
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Machine Learning
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - Checking It Twice
CloudTweaks Comic
The Lighter Side Of The Cloud - iPatch

CLOUDBUZZ NEWS

Oracle Buys DataScience.com

Oracle Buys DataScience.com

Adds Leading Data Science Platform to the Oracle Cloud, Enabling Customers to Fully Utilize Machine Learning Oracle today announced that it has signed an agreement to acquire DataScience.com, whose platform centralizes data science tools, projects ...
Researchers combine wearable technology and AI to predict the onset of health problems

Researchers combine wearable technology and AI to predict the onset of health problems

A team of Waterloo researchers found that applying artificial intelligence to the right combination of data retrieved from wearable technology may detect whether your health is failing. The study, which involved researchers from Waterloo’s Faculties ...
Cambridge Analytica files for bankruptcy in U.S. following Facebook debacle

Cambridge Analytica files for bankruptcy in U.S. following Facebook debacle

(Reuters) - Cambridge Analytica, the political consultancy at the center of Facebook Inc’s (FB.O) privacy scandal, filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in the United States late on Thursday. This past March allegations surfaced that Cambridge ...